top of page
episode-hero.jpg

Is the Mid-Range Agency Dead?

Episode #

232

November 13, 2026

The Agency Growth Podcast

Episode #

232

Is the Mid-Range Agency Dead?

00:00 / 01:04
The Agency Growth Podcast:  Is the Mid-Range Agency Dead? | Episode 232 Cover Art
  • [00:00:48] Jake Hundley

    Okay, first. How's Thailand?


    [00:01:00] Cody

    I got a lot I can try to condense down into a reasonable amount of time. That's good. There's bad. Overall good. Overall I'm a fan. I like it.


    [00:01:16] Cody

    But... There are some things that... i There might be hot takes. ever now. I haven't heard other people tell them to me. ah until coming here. But now that. I am here, they have told me the same thing.


    [00:01:30] Cody

    So. Do you want me to say the bads? Should do I say the good? Like what?


    [00:01:30] Jake Hundley

    Um...


    [00:01:31] Cody

    Does it?


    [00:01:32] Jake Hundley

    Yeah, say we'll say the set start with the start with the goods.


    [00:01:37] Cody

    Um... it's super cheap It's awesome. Right. I love that cost of living everything. bike. Grab, which is their Uber here, is is really cheap and affordable comparatively.


    [00:01:50] Cody

    Food's cheap. um People are generally nice Right. I mean, you have that. Everywhere as long as you're in the right crowds But... And the vibe is fun. It's...


    [00:02:08] Cody

    Um... ambitious. It feels like it, but it's also chill. So that combo is really cool. Okay, that was the good stuff. Bad. Amen.


    [00:02:12] Cody

    The food is mid for me and I feel bad saying it. It just doesn't hit.


    [00:02:17] Jake Hundley

    So you're like you're like, man, Grab is so cheap, but also the food is not great.


    [00:02:22] Cody

    I recognize


    [00:02:23] Cody

    I recognize I'm a fat American. And I am addicted to sugar. There's just no sugar in anything. Right. Like I've been drinking regular sodas. Just to get my my fix Whereas normally and Bye.


    [00:02:42] Cody

    you know. I'm on a i a zero or diet guy. So that and then it extends into desserts To which is just. Uh... Yeah, I can't get my sugar fix with much of anything.


    [00:02:55] Cody

    Been eating a lot of Skittles. That's kind of the the middle ground that I found. Because I just... Buy a lot of those. But. Yeah. like i've tried actual proper desserts i did have one brownie and ice cream once that was pretty good Bye.


    [00:03:05] Cody

    Otherwise... Uh... I don't know how I would get my my sugar fix.


    [00:03:09] Jake Hundley

    You know, I don't think there was, well, I guess on the resorts in Mexico, there's a lot of sugar, but. Like as far as like food anywhere, there really isn't a lot of sugar. so It was funny because... because the I can't remember who on the team was just like, just put your own sugar on the food.


    [00:03:20] Jake Hundley

    I was like, it's not the same. It's not the same. he You can't.


    [00:03:27] Cody

    Well for what it's worth I've done that too right like Frosted Flakes


    [00:03:29] Jake Hundley

    but


    [00:03:30] Cody

    They're just flakes here. Right. There's no frosted. or even if they do say frosted like i don't believe you it's like mildly frosted. So I'm definitely putting my own sugar on breakfast in the morning.


    [00:03:43] Jake Hundley

    Do you think like Kellogg's does that just to like make it cheaper to like, hey, this batch is going to Thailand. Don't put any of the sugar on it.


    [00:03:50] Cody

    the they do have kellogg's here and the specifically the frosted flakes I shouldn't rip on that. Like, it's fine. They they have enough sugar. But it's funny because the but like the packaging itself.


    [00:04:05] Cody

    is Almost like... A sugar shot. because you pour it and it's like the equivalent of a small cup. So I bought like three of them. so that I could have A decent.


    [00:04:15] Cody

    sized a breakfast meal thing. Right? But you...


    [00:04:21] Jake Hundley

    you you're You're buying more than one and everyone's looking at you like, what are you doing? It's so much sugar.


    [00:04:24] Cody

    I know, I just wanna, I'm telling, I mean, they know. right they know because they look at me but i'm like look i'm american I need. Sugar. On. Drib. Just...


    [00:04:32] Cody

    Just put it straight to my veins.


    [00:04:36] Jake Hundley

    That's it. su laura needs a So like salt on drip. Because, like... she salts it Dude, she salts her ramen noodles, but when she could have those, it it was crazy.


    [00:04:45] Jake Hundley

    I was like, that rama' like ramen have like 1 ,000 % of your sodium.


    [00:04:49] Cody

    That's brave. Yeah.


    [00:04:53] Jake Hundley

    Uh, And. there We were on a plane one time and she or she ordered a like a tomato juice or a V8 or whatever. insurers second one okay cool insurers the third one and then the But... Flight attendant like shamed her. She goes,


    [00:05:08] Jake Hundley

    she goes Are you sure? That's a lot of sodium. and la just Lauren just goes. Yeah, I want my third VA. Hmph.


    [00:05:14] Cody

    That's so funny. to To have a stranger be like objectively concerned about your health. for your choices. That's so funny


    [00:05:22] Jake Hundley

    And it's not like Lauren has a very like. normal like normal body style like you and me and it's like it's not like she's like like a large woman that has like hypertension or something. like


    [00:05:32] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:05:36] Jake Hundley

    Heh. All right. but Cool. Well, I'm glad you're enjoying Thailand. Uh, Is this going to be your new your new destination?


    [00:05:43] Cody

    Yeah. ah We're going to have to talk about it, but we feel good about it. um And I think there will be. a move here in the future.


    [00:05:53] Jake Hundley

    Hell yeah, dude. That's awesome. Who would have thought? It's eight years ago


    [00:05:58] Cody

    Yeah. No idea. No clue


    [00:06:02] Jake Hundley

    Sick. All right, business. I saw you had put an article in here.


    [00:06:06] Cody

    Business.


    [00:06:09] Jake Hundley

    which is hilarious because I was going to put the exact same article. And. there. I saw.


    [00:06:12] Cody

    It's huge.


    [00:06:14] Jake Hundley

    yeah i saw it popped up in stacked marketer and i saw i've been seeing it on linkedin too and hearing chatter of it but i've been so distracted with stuff going on i never grow that I haven't really looked into it. ah But you put it in here, so you kick it off.


    [00:06:27] Cody

    Yeah, I mean... the The title is it's straight from Jack GPT. from OpenAI introducing businesses. in chat gbt And...


    [00:06:37] Cody

    The premise being you're finally going to get. GPT Search Console. Right?


    [00:06:47] Jake Hundley

    Not not gonna get it's here Search console for GPT is here.


    [00:06:49] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:06:53] Jake Hundley

    Aye. Yeah, so I i actually just signed us up for this, by the way. um I verified Evergrow on it.


    [00:06:55] Cody

    Nice.


    [00:06:58] Jake Hundley

    And like the verification options was weird because like you could get a text. to like the business phone number. I guess to just pick it from the site. Um,


    [00:07:05] Cody

    Interesting.


    [00:07:11] Jake Hundley

    assuming that your number can actually be texted, or you can do the the DNS route. You can verify it. through that route Those are the only two options that it gave me. Once I logged in, it wants me to verify my identity with ah with an ID. It's just an option. It's not like a... You have to do this before looking at anything Um, I invited Eva to it. I'm gonna invite you to it too. um


    [00:07:33] Cody

    cool


    [00:07:36] Jake Hundley

    And. i Then... And then I guess like I was asking it because I haven't really explored it a lot because I did this like five minutes before the recording. But. um I guess you can add.


    [00:07:45] Jake Hundley

    You can add, see if I hit add business. Let's do like... All-American turf. I'm gonna blip that out. We said blip that out.


    [00:07:59] Jake Hundley

    ah What was that, like seven minutes in? Uh, ah i me add Let me add one of our clients here. Uh... Yeah.


    [00:08:04] Jake Hundley

    There it is. I guess they haven't. Obviously, no one's claimed it. So, well, allegedly, according to ChatGPT. because i I just jumped over to my messages.


    [00:08:21] Jake Hundley

    I asked if multiple multiple people can manage one listing and then. And here it says. Um, was, uh... Are you asking because you want your agency to manage multiple clients? uh clients chat GPT search console accounts while each client also retains access.


    [00:08:35] Jake Hundley

    um Oh, i I should just say yes. I didn't respond to that. i was um So. let's see what it says good news openai explicitly supports this agency client arrangement Uh,


    [00:08:54] Cody

    great We like that.


    [00:08:58] Jake Hundley

    so The admin who claimed your... Let's see. it The admin who claimed your business can add teammates in Business Hub and grant agency access to manage the business or its agents. ah So...


    [00:09:06] Jake Hundley

    Oh, so you add agency team members. So it's not like ah it's not like meta. business manager where you like add ah like ah an entity. Um, So yeah we would just use our normal like.


    [00:09:19] Jake Hundley

    Email that. all the team has access to to get. into there. ChatGPT Search Console. So.


    [00:09:25] Cody

    Makes sense.


    [00:09:30] Jake Hundley

    Cool. Just another thing to look at. Over 50 accounts. So. Ha ha. um it's It's nice because there's been a lot of... stuff going on lately about how like Google is obfuscating.


    [00:09:38] Jake Hundley

    Um... like their like their ap like or their search results but via api so like none of the reporting tools are allegedly accurate anymore i don't know how accurate that claim is but i've been seeing it like left right and sideways like Everybody on LinkedIn or Twitter or whatever are saying that.


    [00:10:01] Jake Hundley

    I. So Google is like, I don't know if you're familiar with this, but like Google. like For like Ahrefs and SEMrush, when they track a query and they go to Google using the API and they search that query, Google is seeding them and like intentionally incorrect information.


    [00:10:06] Jake Hundley

    like incorrect search results.


    [00:10:25] Cody

    I've heard this yeah i've heard about it


    [00:10:33] Jake Hundley

    So like the tools are not accurate. again allegedly right because i don't know how how you can prove it or disprove it Um, Bye. I feel like that alone kind of shakes up an entire industry.


    [00:10:41] Jake Hundley

    Um... But it has made me happy that we don't pay for search tools.


    [00:10:43] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:10:46] Cody

    Yeah. It's fun.


    [00:10:50] Cody

    The everything that. Uh... Bots. are doing. is just it's so hard to keep up with. at the moment. I had that call.


    [00:11:00] Cody

    with Stripe. that I mentioned.


    [00:11:05] Jake Hundley

    Oh yeah.


    [00:11:08] Cody

    And they were asking me some questions. about ah they They just released, I didn't even know that they released it. I was just doing something in Claude. And.


    [00:11:15] Cody

    um ended up providing limited access in order to to gather some information. And... when they were


    [00:11:21] Jake Hundley

    Was it like an MC was like an MCP?


    [00:11:23] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:11:24] Jake Hundley

    Oh, okay.


    [00:11:25] Cody

    Yeah. But... That's brand new. Like it just happened. So I got this ghost email. I say ghost. I don't know who this person is. I just get this email from Stripe. That's like, hey. I'm a part of this team and you did this. I'm like, that's creepy. But sure, we'll go with that. um and they wanted to talk about it and i'm i'm talking um i'm like i had no idea that you even released this I didn't know that this just happened.


    [00:11:40] Cody

    um And. I can't keep up with everything that is just happening right now because everything is just happening. Okay. I'm really glad that you just. did that in real time about the the chat GPT dashboard because I'm like, I've heard about it. I haven't played with it. And until. you know um unless we do some of these things in real time it's like It's just so hard.


    [00:11:55] Jake Hundley

    Things are moving really fast right now. like Just just everywhere and like I'm i'm getting like slightly overwhelmed. a little bit but Um, so i keep i keep like a notebook here and i write in it every day i'm like okay what's What's the next thing I need to tackle? What's the next thing I need to explore? Like I still have Cloudflare on my list.


    [00:12:10] Jake Hundley

    of just going through and seeing everything cloudflare could do i still have cloud my list i have like There are tools I want to vibe code, but it's like, do I use an all-in-one solution like Replit or do I go to, do do I kind of... like build my own ah infrastructure.


    [00:12:43] Jake Hundley

    And then like, what are the trade-offs between that? And part of that, actually the biggest reason for a lot of this is... is that kind of the reason why we're talking today. Um, about I guess the title of this episode, which as we record these, we never actually have the title. So it's kind of my working title is is Middle Tier Agencies Are Drying Up.


    [00:13:00] Jake Hundley

    And. So there's like just, just. Categorically, right? There's low tier agencies that are that are... charging i don't know anywhere from two to $500 a month or two to 200. to $1 ,000 a month for whatever marketing services. Then you have like mid-tier agencies who are like...


    [00:13:15] Jake Hundley

    No. a thousand dollars or three thousand dollars a month and then you have like high ticket agencies that are three thousand dollars a month and higher So. It all started because one of our competitors and friend, ah someone who was on this podcast, Tyler Hoyt.


    [00:13:27] Jake Hundley

    He posted on Facebook about a week ago. that i just caught my attention a few days ago It says, it starts off, it says middle tier agency, middle tier marketing is gone. agencies have shifted one or two directions now. low ticket or high ticket.


    [00:13:42] Jake Hundley

    Gone are the days that you're going to find an experienced quality marketing team to run the show for you for $1 ,500 a month. You're either going to get a done with you or do it yourself offer for under $500 a month.


    [00:13:52] Jake Hundley

    or you're going to get a done for you offer that costs $3 ,000 to $5 ,000 a month. Anything done for you under that is just garbage now. or they're brand new. Real marketing systems require teams to run them, not one person trying to do SEO ad systems. the costs required to provide the quality, not just hiring ops for VAs.


    [00:14:15] Jake Hundley

    has made a 1500 done for you marketing system nearly impossible to deliver So. i my my knee-jerk reaction to that was like no like you're that's wrong because I mean...


    [00:14:23] Jake Hundley

    We essentially do it like our. our our base package. rate $6 .50 a month. That includes Google Ads and SEO. But then... ah When I read into what he's talking about. where it's more about the systems and not just running the ads.


    [00:14:38] Jake Hundley

    we I mean, we've talked about it multiple times on this podcast about... How? The marketing. Lately has just not been Worth it. ah for our clients because they also need a system to facilitate the leads, which is something we're building. we're we're building up and building onto.


    [00:14:46] Jake Hundley

    You add that to our low ticket $650, and then suddenly we're going to be at the $1 ,500 range, still only offering ads and SEO, but then the way to facilitate those as well. You add one more service onto that, like Facebook ads or Yelp or whatever, and suddenly we're pushing $3 ,000. for our management And...


    [00:15:02] Jake Hundley

    I just, I was like, Hey. we I mean he's kind of right.


    [00:15:22] Cody

    Yeah. I agree with the premise. I don't. Agree with the details. I think... This works as a good blanket statement in order to get people's attention which he is good at doing so That's why I would do it that way and I understand why he is I think.


    [00:15:27] Cody

    middle tier. pricing. is still here. I think middle tier accommodation. is gone. This idea that you are going to pay somewhere between.


    [00:15:51] Cody

    i don't know 1500 and 2500 And. everybody I mean... everybody All the agencies. out there are going to cooperate with all of your individual CMSs.


    [00:16:05] Cody

    tools whatever it is youre that you're using and say yeah no problem we're going to integrate it with all of our things and figure out the custom solutions and vibe code all that no it's not that's not going to happen it's gone it's done the reason why the pricing works in that middle ground is when you take out all of the personality All of the...


    [00:16:31] Cody

    nuances. those little things that you normally Um, People want to believe that they care about. You know, it's it's the Ferrari versus Honda thing. like You want those as preferences, but you don't have the budget.


    [00:16:44] Cody

    for them, so... you know you can always say like oh yeah i want this i want that i want these custom things and Actually. OK, here's an offshoot. This is one I almost. I almost posted this and then I didn't and I probably just should have, but.


    [00:16:54] Cody

    My favorite thing happening right now. is Every single... Guy. complaining. about cookie cutter templated.


    [00:17:01] Cody

    website designs. Is going out. and vibe coding a website that looks...


    [00:17:25] Jake Hundley

    ah


    [00:17:28] Cody

    like every single other. cookie cutter vibe coded website. And if you give it two years.


    [00:17:30] Jake Hundley

    that's


    [00:17:31] Cody

    They're going to look back and go, ah, yeah, now they all look the same. Right?


    [00:17:34] Jake Hundley

    It's so easy to tell when when something is vibe coded. uh, and And there's a couple of people on Facebook that are like, I don't know why we called this. like I'm like, okay, so what you... you hand you custom coded something that looks exactly like what ai can reproduce Not can, but what exactly what. It does reproduce.


    [00:17:37] Jake Hundley

    Um, But like we're we're working on custom templates right now for for our client sites, except we're actually bringing in a designer. to to design it. ah versus just using AI to...


    [00:17:53] Jake Hundley

    to pump it out. But we recently did ah one of those studies. ah Actually, it got brought up in ah in a client call yesterday. Um, and And this is actually relevant to one of my stories, too. um But, uh...


    [00:18:11] Jake Hundley

    But i did want I did want people to write this down. When you said... ah That. middle tier. The middle tier pricing isn't. dead, military accommodation is dead. And I was like, that is so. true because when i think of like other agencies or what they're doing out there like i can't remember if tyler is doing this or if other agencies are doing this but um they're taking like their clients crm data and then porting it into google ads for like better matched convert or better matched audiences.


    [00:18:16] Jake Hundley

    And I. Like. Just being in this industry for eight years, we both know that that data is really not significant enough to make. any kind of impact.


    [00:18:44] Jake Hundley

    um let alone at the price that we're offering it at So. um when you have like little nuanced things like that and you're like this is how you do it 100 like this is how you're the best marketer or the best PPC person is you have to do this for every client. Yeah. You're going to have to charge a lot. Like you're going to have to be a high tier agency. You have to pick the things that you're going to do and not do.


    [00:18:58] Jake Hundley

    based on your pricing. One of the things that we don't do is we don't do those custom matched audiences because every system that we then try to bring into. Google Ads or Facebook or whatever.


    [00:19:15] Jake Hundley

    um is going to be that much more. or that. Much is it is that right that much more effort?


    [00:19:35] Cody

    Yeah, that works


    [00:19:39] Jake Hundley

    a scene It just felt i felt really weird.


    [00:19:40] Cody

    No, that's good.


    [00:19:42] Jake Hundley

    um


    [00:19:43] Cody

    That's good


    [00:19:44] Jake Hundley

    Anyways, it's going to be that much more effort. uh that didn't feel weird at all uh but like when you just said it fast it's like oh it works Alright. And. And there has, you have to like.


    [00:19:54] Jake Hundley

    understand what you're charging. And then. Figure out what you're willing to give up. on or or let go. But this this client call I was talking about with the website templates. um So even I were on this and we were explaining how like what we we're going to do moving forward after we get some of these SEO updates done.


    [00:20:09] Jake Hundley

    And one of them was just like UX optimization because this was a site that we had taken on. versus one that we had built and i was explaining to them how their conversion rate is like less than half of what our our typical site conversion rate is.


    [00:20:31] Jake Hundley

    and we just and then i was like yeah i actually even just posted a study on our website about it about how we looked at all of our sites. And found that. the average conversion rate is um I think in most cases more than double.


    [00:20:47] Jake Hundley

    the conversion rate of the sites that we take on. Um, And there's nothing like super scientific about it because it's like it's our own data that we're just looking at. um And it's not super controlled, but...


    [00:20:53] Jake Hundley

    um it is just an observation it doesn't tell us like why The sites are performing better. um But we can make our our kind of subjective guesses. um But having said that, like ah we're working with a designer to kind of re.


    [00:21:05] Jake Hundley

    design some templates and build some more templates. with with the thought of our actual templates included. because I don't want to create a bunch of templates and then all of a sudden have them perform poorly.


    [00:21:20] Jake Hundley

    um just because they look pretty. So. Um...


    [00:21:25] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:21:30] Jake Hundley

    See ya. Uh... On that same note for that client. This is one of so this is this is my so one of my stories here. so this is Um,


    [00:21:37] Jake Hundley

    I was prepping for this call because this this client site is something that we took on. Uh... And they have. Like over a thousand pages, mostly because they're not just like a landscaper, but they're also a ah they also have a garden center.


    [00:21:50] Jake Hundley

    And so they list their products on our site. in an ecom way except they don't sell their products on site they only sell it at the actual location. so um it's a wix studio site so i had to so we had to like do some custom stuff to remove all pricing and ordering options but they still nonetheless let's have those pages There's a lot of SEO stuff to do. um And then...


    [00:22:02] Jake Hundley

    We're also... their their site was an absolute mess when we took it over like just just chaotic and it's one of those things where it's like man i really wish we would have just rebuilt the site um just said too bad it's going to be 15k to rebuild it because there's so much here but we're gonna do it right uh we didn't do it that way we took it on And.


    [00:22:15] Jake Hundley

    There. um They had tons of location pages that we had to get rid of. um they had all kinds of service pages that were like duplicate So we had to reorganize and restructure those.


    [00:22:33] Jake Hundley

    And then we had to... um build like additional pages that made sense that just weren't the information wasn't there. um Why I'm bringing this up. is because I was looking at their... their Google Analytics or their Google Search Console.


    [00:22:41] Jake Hundley

    And technically. Their SEO has gotten worse. since We... came on. And I was so I was looking at this and I was like, why? or why like we're ranking higher on average but like the the the the queries that we want to be targeting like the money queries have just absolutely fallen off Like completely.


    [00:23:00] Jake Hundley

    I'm like well that's kind of a problem. um So I was looking at the pages and I realized i realized something. What I realized was that. um All of these pages that are new, that are like new structure, new hierarchy um for services, all the things that we replicate on our actual client websites that we build.


    [00:23:22] Jake Hundley

    were never submitted for indexing. and Google. Um,


    [00:23:35] Cody

    So we were just waiting.


    [00:23:40] Jake Hundley

    Yeah, we were just waiting for them to get indexed and they weren't getting indexed because this wasn't a site that was constantly getting. Getting crawled. Um, So. I went and submitted those money pages for indexing. But then remember, the site has like a thousand pages. So like what is and isn't indexed? I can't just go through and then like arbitrarily determine what's important, and what's not. Like I know the money pages in the menu, the service pages are the ones that should be indexed.


    [00:23:53] Jake Hundley

    Um, And when you submit a page for indexing, if it's like a main page or like even a blog page that would rank for something. um For some reason. I have a very high success rate of getting pages. to get indexed on Google just by requesting. I don't know if everybody everybody else experiences that too, but when I just request a page to get indexed, it gets indexed. um So.


    [00:24:10] Jake Hundley

    Um, So I'm i'm hoping like once those get published, like we start seeing an improved rank. But I was thinking. uh Man. You're really cool. if we had a tool. They could just tell us monthly which pages are supposed to be indexed and which pages have fallen out of the index.


    [00:24:31] Jake Hundley

    And then every month we would go in and do the SEO. And that's one of those checklists, one of those deliverables that we do. We submit a page for re-indexing if it's fallen out of the index. Uh, And that would give us like a roadmap for these larger client sites that that are like this ah as well.


    [00:24:39] Jake Hundley

    And so I was looking at tools and like e SE ranking was coming up because I've used them in the past. They would be affordable. I've used like looking up Ahrefs. looking up other tools. ah Indexly was another one because it was just pared down to exactly what I needed.


    [00:24:59] Jake Hundley

    um But. Looking at the pricing of them like index Lee was let's look ah pricing. This is all relevant to what we're talking about. Indexly 10 sites, $4 .99 a month.


    [00:25:14] Jake Hundley

    Bro. No. I like it What? I'm guessing this is meant for so this is meant for like index like it's I think it's meant to get like your actual site.


    [00:25:18] Jake Hundley

    indexed across.


    [00:25:28] Cody

    wait what how much


    [00:25:32] Jake Hundley

    $4 .99 a month. $499 a month.


    [00:25:35] Cody

    Wait what?


    [00:25:40] Jake Hundley

    ten For 10 sites. Okay, so what what i'm what I'm guessing this tool is... is that it it submits your links to like web 2 .0 things to get your site indexed


    [00:25:47] Cody

    Uh, okay.


    [00:25:50] Jake Hundley

    Um, versus like the thing that I actually need, which is just monitoring. basically. Um, monitoring All I needed to do is look at the XML sitemap. And then I need to compare it to, like, I need to i need it to connect to Google Search Console.


    [00:26:07] Jake Hundley

    And. basically match reports up and then just tell me what's not in Search Console's index. Um, So then I was looking at ah pricing for e SE ranking.


    [00:26:13] Jake Hundley

    and that's based on like campaigns or like projects, I guess. $280 a month. for 30 projects i'm like great that'll tackle all of our marketing clients right now But it's still $230 a month. like that's That's like half of the cost that we were paying for HubSpot.


    [00:26:28] Jake Hundley

    So and just just to do this index check. So that's why I was... kind of looking at um it's like okay so we need to start looking at like tools like claude can claude do this can i can i vibe code something on replit and just connect google sheets with google search console and then like post the XML sitemap.


    [00:26:33] Jake Hundley

    for xml sitemap for all of our clients in that sheet they just have like the the UI. give us this report. Um, So anyways.


    [00:26:51] Jake Hundley

    um I'm going to do that. I'm going to look into that route, the the AI vibe coding route. um But when I was looking at these tools, what I'd realized was that. The...


    [00:27:20] Jake Hundley

    I think a lot of the reasons is why these mid-tier agencies are dying. is because these tools are getting so expensive. And you can't just. Like. And this is one reason, right? like Um,


    [00:27:27] Jake Hundley

    You look at all of our peers, all of our peers have tons of tools. um Caesar, I'm sure. I think again at one point he had SEMrush and Ahrefs. And then he has what converts. And then he has like... like and like think i think caesar is the embodiment of like the average solo agency owner


    [00:27:32] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:27:39] Jake Hundley

    Yeah.


    [00:27:48] Cody

    Yeah, yeah


    [00:27:53] Jake Hundley

    And he's raised his prices like three times in one year. like You can't. You can't have. low to mid tier pricing. If you need these tools to help facilitate the work you're getting done between all your clients.


    [00:28:00] Cody

    Yeah. I don't know You're going to go. that This is the nature of the world with everything in every business is are you going to. Move down.


    [00:28:14] Cody

    for mass appeal. because you want the quantity. of consumers that is available there. Or are you going to double down on expertise?


    [00:28:40] Cody

    Charge premium. Whittle down the quantity of accounts that you have And... do everything. And. I don't know.


    [00:28:50] Cody

    But we just had a discovery call. recently. Where? the ladder. Right. The high premium expertize was the their realm.


    [00:29:08] Cody

    right that's really what they did they charged an extra and Uh, their skill more than anything. people-ing. Right. So it has nothing to do with any of the stuff that we're talking about here. It's just, can you talk to these people?


    [00:29:27] Cody

    in a way that it's accommodating to everybody else's egos. and gets everybody in the room to cooperate you're just a professional mediator in a way i mean yeah you have the agency bar where you're actually doing agency things but Let's be honest. like When you're charging that premium, that is your skill.


    [00:29:30] Cody

    Everybody, like if we're. if We're saying that the skills the hard skills. are relatively transferable. Then... And you're not competing on price. then the skill that you're selling is your ability to...


    [00:29:44] Cody

    Schmills. um The flip side being... You're gonna be constantly Aware. of pricing.


    [00:29:53] Cody

    relatively aware of what your competitors are doing if they are starting to you know tread into your territory or or something like that some I mean, we've seen people making really big shifts. I was just... jake i was just telling you about um Somebody that.


    [00:30:10] Cody

    Uh, basically I don't want to say split their company. maybe Maybe that's what they did. There's two arms of it now with the parent company and half of it is not even marketing.


    [00:30:25] Cody

    Any more? um And. It's just weird what all this is opening up. as people try to figure out


    [00:30:29] Jake Hundley

    Wait we've seen that?


    [00:30:31] Cody

    Hm? Yeah.


    [00:30:33] Jake Hundley

    Was it? oh


    [00:30:36] Cody

    He's doing um What is it? It's... I don't know if it's white labeling, but it's AI voice. stuff. Right.


    [00:30:42] Jake Hundley

    Oh. Oh, yeah, yeah, okay, okay, yep, yep.


    [00:30:45] Cody

    Yeah. So in a way, I mean it's not too dissimilar from us. but That's a way that's its potential solution to try to be competitive with pricing when you are at this.


    [00:30:50] Cody

    Lower. area. in in this I don't know. in the trenches. Because that's what it feels like. when you know, we It bothers me when we have calls.


    [00:31:01] Cody

    with other agency owners. And they say things like, yeah, but who cares about that? that little money when you're in our position and i'm like no we do you don't understand like you when you're saying our position you're taking this high and mighty position of oh we're better we're amazing we're so much cooler than everybody else and we charge a premium for it and it's like Okay.


    [00:31:05] Cody

    That's cool. That's your position. That doesn't mean that's who you are. And it doesn't belittle the people who aren't doing that and who are. doing price competitive stuff. We're trying to make productized solutions because they would rather compete at scale instead of I...


    [00:31:20] Cody

    you know catering to Schmoozing.


    [00:31:33] Cody

    I'm going off. I don't know. I lost it i lost the thread.


    [00:31:45] Jake Hundley

    No, no. No, it... It's great. I was talking to, I can't remember who I was talking to recently. It might've been Grace, but I was explaining to her that like. um I don't.


    [00:31:54] Jake Hundley

    I don't like taking advice from other agency owners because every agency owner is going to be like, you know, you need to be like a more hired. You need to be higher ticket. Like you need to be $3 ,000 a month. Like that's what everyone else is doing. And it's like, that's not what I want because it's going to require.


    [00:32:10] Jake Hundley

    schmoozing. It's going to require those client calls that I don't want to do. It's it's it's those things that even I did for years at an agency. and And that's not what the business model is here. And that's fine, but it's like...


    [00:32:25] Jake Hundley

    Every business model is... is Every agency business model that I'm running into is is different now. It's becoming like you're either following somebody else's blueprint. or you're creating your own because nothing else works out for you.


    [00:32:46] Jake Hundley

    um like from a lifestyle perspective. So I would rather compete at scale because then... um It sounds weird to say it. We can be more impersonal. We can be more transactional. And that's kind of the point.


    [00:32:50] Jake Hundley

    Um,


    [00:32:55] Cody

    we We live in an industry where we can do that too though Like I I think a lot of people who are on the flip side are afraid. that They're very afraid. and that's this is actually the rebuttal to what i was saying before which is that they can't go to their clients and say,


    [00:33:14] Cody

    What were you expecting at this price point? Right.


    [00:33:20] Jake Hundley

    Yeah.


    [00:33:22] Cody

    Like, what did you think? you Went. to Walmart. and buy the TV for 90 bucks. And it lasted. three years and then it broke on you. Like...


    [00:33:25] Cody

    Dude. What were your expectations here? That you were going to... Hand this down to your grandchildren. Like...


    [00:33:30] Jake Hundley

    ah


    [00:33:34] Cody

    Like I just. We can say that sort of stuff. We really can. And in a way that isn't. offensive because they are our clients are also um have to be relatively.


    [00:33:44] Cody

    price conscious when dealing with their customers too. But if you aren't doing that and you're on the flip side position, then you're. Terrified. to talk to your clients in that way because you're worried that they're going to leave and you've got a whole lot more money in one place that if they do leave, it's a problem.


    [00:33:55] Jake Hundley

    Well, maybe that's why. That's why I like this product as approach because. They're less. the the the less communication we have with them. the less that needs to be explained. and Being like, what did you expect? Well, it's like.


    [00:34:02] Jake Hundley

    They have eventually they have no one like on this bottom tier they have no one to say I expect more. Right. Cause it's just. you click checkout for the marketing services online.


    [00:34:16] Jake Hundley

    And then...


    [00:34:25] Cody

    Yeah.


    [00:34:30] Jake Hundley

    you know and then are upset that you're not getting a a call from a rep every month um So. Obviously like, you know, everybody listening. we're obviously very ah ROI and lead driven. So like, that's the whole purpose. And if we weren't, we wouldn't have a successful. business model.


    [00:34:35] Jake Hundley

    Um, But. The last thing I had in here was um I just read read my notes here. but So what tyler what Tyler is saying is true, but it doesn't mean you can't have lower cost services or even mid-tier range services.


    [00:34:48] Jake Hundley

    So there's ah there's there's just always going to be a pain point that your clients won't have solved. So like those higher end services, those higher end... marketing agencies. They're designed to be full service or. or cover all of the needs. A client comes to you and says,


    [00:35:01] Jake Hundley

    Um, I need... to grow in sales. Uh, like, i know so. A marketing agency might say, okay, you need more leads then. um like a full service agency says You need leads. You need a follow-up system. You need. um You need to be able to track your ROI. You need to be able to have all these things in place to know that your marketing is doing.


    [00:35:06] Jake Hundley

    um doing well for you. Whereas like when we come in and we deliver the leads, we actually expect our clients to... to to recognize that their marketing is doing well on their own versus us telling them.


    [00:35:16] Jake Hundley

    right And we've set our reports up to do that, to be very straightforward. ah But the problem is with... um with our marketing is that tracking.


    [00:35:21] Jake Hundley

    ah like down to the lead isn't inherently provided. So like that's being worked into like another tier, which is going to bump us up into the mid tier, right? Just tracking the leads in ah ROI. um We expect our clients to have processes internally to handle that.


    [00:35:26] Jake Hundley

    Problem is, is the majority of them don't. So I they don't even have like a really good internal system to follow up on leads So when they get leads and this is this goes back to the call we just had you yesterday um they were complaining about.


    [00:35:50] Jake Hundley

    local service ads. Then I was looking at local service ads. They haven't. marked a single one as archived or booked they haven't put a note in a single one of them they haven't done anything in a single one of them. They're like.


    [00:35:54] Jake Hundley

    And he he said, like, I just want. Like I don't need. Um, I don't need 10 bad leads. I need one good lead. And I was like, that's great. But the one good lead is in those 10 leads.


    [00:36:04] Jake Hundley

    Like, you you can't you can't just get... the Um, the The one lead. I was like, now, which I told him. like straight to his face. I said, what you want doesnt exist.


    [00:36:11] Jake Hundley

    You can't just turn something on and say, I only want a good leads. It doesn't work that way. What you can do is what we're actually working on, which is filtering out all the bad leads. So it appears as if you're only getting the good leads. You're just done the wiser.


    [00:36:19] Jake Hundley

    I'm like, that's what we're working on because it's a it's a problem. that a lot of our clients have that right there is a system Like that is the system. Those are the systems that Tyler is offering to his clients on top of.


    [00:36:27] Jake Hundley

    his marketing services the things that we don't have the things that we're neglecting because of our price point So. Um... I have this in here, but it says it's offering low to mid range services appeals to clients that don't have the ability. to facilitate those leads so when you


    [00:36:43] Jake Hundley

    ah when you charge a low amount. but you provide the leads and they don't have a point to facilitate it or or an operation to facilitate it, that pain point is going to be. We're getting a lot of bad leads.


    [00:36:53] Jake Hundley

    We don't know how to source the good ones from these, or we don't have a good speed to lead process. Um, If you're offering high-range services, um Those appeal to clients that do have those in place, but the pain point is your pricing.


    [00:37:17] Jake Hundley

    So like there's always going to be a pain point no matter what. type of service that you offer. And so what Tyler is saying is true is like, yeah, the mid to your full service is dead.


    [00:37:37] Jake Hundley

    But I think the mid-tier full service has kind of always been dead. Or it's been like a like it's been like in a... um a temporary accommodation. to decide whether you're low tier or high tier.


    [00:37:51] Cody

    Yeah, it's like it exists. Did it exist? It shouldn't. It's just not good. Like don't go there. It's not a good place to be. It's not going to be. Easy, it's gonna be ugly.


    [00:38:09] Cody

    Like... I wrote down I think. if you want proof that mid-tier pricing I'm not going to say agency, but just the pricing. still exists. It's just that our clients are asking for it.


    [00:38:18] Cody

    Right. And if you operate from a business perspective and not just a marketing perspective, you know what it's like when your business grows linearly and you have linearly more money.


    [00:38:40] Cody

    You go, hey, I have some more money. right i went from having sub 1k i have over 1k i don't have 5k Right? But I still want your help growing more.


    [00:38:46] Cody

    That's where i've caught our clients have told us that basically without saying it verbatim like that. But that's basically what they've said. I have more money. I want more leads. It's going to be ugly. I need your help in general. But...


    [00:39:04] Cody

    I want to give you more. Because I'm not yet there. And. We're in that spot. And a lot of people. if you start especially if you start at that small tier and you help people grow.


    [00:39:19] Cody

    you're going to end up in that spot too. So. It does exist. It's not easy. And. Our solution is always telling you that productization is a beautiful wonderful thing that will keep your sanity in check while you keep growing past that point.


    [00:39:25] Cody

    And then if you do find instead that you're like, man. Uh... I think it's usually a personality thing. I really do. Like if you start going down productization and and it's not.


    [00:39:45] Cody

    it doesn't click for you it doesn't work for you then maybe go and explore just jumping up to the high end. because um Hey. it's it takes a different kind of brain. I think.


    [00:40:02] Cody

    or a different kind of patients. I don't know. It's a different personality no matter what.


    [00:40:11] Jake Hundley

    Yeah, I think ah the easiest way to to explain productization, I think, to a full service agency is like. Take your full service whether it's like five thousand dollars a month And then.


    [00:40:16] Jake Hundley

    Divide it into five separate services. or for separate services. Right. Like separate, like create those boundaries. And yeah, you're you're going to have to drop connections. Right. Like. if one of your things is importing contacts from your ah crm um into into Facebook ads for better match rates You're going to you're gonna have to sever that connection. right just like like separate things into four or five categories several connections And then.


    [00:40:38] Jake Hundley

    you sell those individually. That's productization. And then being a low tier agency is selling one of those. And then being a mid-tier agency is selling two or three of those. And the full service is... bolting all those together.


    [00:40:43] Jake Hundley

    um And then you can create those cross those, those relationships. um that's what That's what we're doing. So for the longest time, we were a low-tier agency because we had no upsell. It was just a foundation and that was it. And then we created the hub and spoke model. for our productization and we were able to start bolting on.


    [00:40:44] Jake Hundley

    additional services, which then created this whole ecosystem of marketing operations. So. Um... Cool. Well, ah in the ah in the Patreon premium version of this, what ah what we're going to talk about, we'll dive deeper into.


    [00:40:59] Jake Hundley

    is um is more on that topic of developing more than one solution not just being a full service agency and not just being a low-tier agency but um having mid-tier options um And then also... leaning on AI to develop those automated solutions versus going for the next tool. Like what do you actually need versus like the whole.


    [00:41:04] Jake Hundley

    Um, you know like the whole suite of of options So. ah Cool. Well, everybody else? Thanks for listening. See you next time.


    [00:41:15] Cody

    See ya.

Show Notes:

[Cold open [Moving to Thailand, Sugar Addictions & Sodium Shaming.] ends at 06:02.]

 

The rumor going around our industry is that the mid-tier agency is dead, but the reality is much more complicated.

 

A colleague recently claimed you either have to sell $500 low-ticket packages or charge over $3,000 for full-service, done-for-you work. We disagree. Mid-tier pricing still works when you set clear limits on custom CRM integrations and how much hands-on support is included.

 

If you want to keep prices in the middle, give each service a clear scope and keep an eye on what it costs to deliver. At Evergrow, that meant using AI to build an SEO index tracker that does what we need without another expensive subscription.

 

We also dive into the new ChatGPT Search Console and how it handles agency-client access. Give this one a listen if you’re trying to figure out where your pricing fits right now.

 

-----

 

MENTIONS IN THE EPISODE:

Article: Introducing Businesses in ChatGPT

https://openai.com/index/introducing-businesses-chatgpt/

 

-----

 

PREMIUM:

Join the Patreon and get exclusive content from this episode with more in-depth advice and hours of bonus content each month:

https://www.agencygrowthpodcast.com/premium

 

-----

 

RESOURCES:

Want the tools and resources we recommend for agencies? Check them out here:

https://www.agencygrowthpod.com/tools

 

-----

 

NEWSLETTER

Want the show in your inbox? Sign up for the newsletter!

https://www.agencygrowthpod.com/newsletter

 

-----

 

COMMUNITY

Looking to join a community of agency owners? Join our Discord!

https://discord.gg/uvHRRRFVRD

 

-----

 

CONTACT

Got something to say? Send us a message:

https://www.agencygrowthpod.com/contact

TL;DL (Too Long, Didn't Listen)

Here's a summary of the episode:

NEVER MISS AN EPISODE

Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly episode updates, new article releases, and more.

bottom of page